Schemes 1 and 2 describe sequential transformation of alkynes M and N. Consider only the major products formed in each step for both the schemes.
NaNH2 (excess)
NaNH2 (2 equivalent)
The correct statement with respect to product Y is
(A)It gives a positive Tollens test and is a functional isomer of X.
(B)It gives a positive Tollens test and is a geometrical isomer of X.
(C)It gives a positive iodoform test and is a functional isomer of X.✓ Correct
(D)It gives a positive iodoform test and is a geometrical isomer of X.
Answer: (C)
Solution
Product Y is formed from Scheme 2. Following the transformations, Y is a ketone with a CH3CO− group (methyl ketone structure). Methyl ketones give a positive iodoform test when treated with I2/NaOH.
Product X from Scheme 1 is an ether, while Y is a ketone. They have the same molecular formula but different functional groups, making them functional isomers.
Y does not give a positive Tollens test because ketones (except α-hydroxy ketones) do not reduce Tollens' reagent. Only aldehydes give a positive Tollens test.
Therefore, Y gives a positive iodoform test and is a functional isomer of X.
JEE Advanced · 2014 · 25 May 2014 · Paper 2 · Single correct option