Consider a sphere of radius R which carries a uniform charge density ρ. If a sphere of radius 2R is carved out of it, as shown the ratio ∣EB∣∣EA∣ of magnitude of electric field EA and EB, respectively, at point A and B due to the remaining portion is:
(A)3418✓ Correct
(B)5417
(C)5418
(D)3421
Answer: (A)
Solution
Picture the hollow as the full sphere superposed on a smaller sphere of equal but opposite charge density filling the cavity. At A, the centre of the cavity and a distance 2R from the centre of the big sphere, the full sphere gives 3ε0ρ(R/2)=6ε0ρR while the carved sphere contributes nothing at its own centre, so EA=6ε0ρR. At B on the surface, a distance R from the centre and 23R from the cavity centre, the full sphere gives 3ε0ρR, and the carved sphere now acts as a point charge of magnitude 34π(2R)3ρ at distance 23R, subtracting 54ε0ρR, so EB=54ε017ρR. The ratio is 17ρR/54ρR/6=6×1754=179=3418.
JEE Main · 2020 · 09 Jan 2020 · Shift 1 · Single correct option